User:Stever/boxford/speedsnfeeds: Difference between revisions
imported>Stever |
imported>Stever No edit summary |
||
(16 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown) | |||
Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
All recipes from personal experience and tested |
All recipes from personal experience and tested on the [[Tools/boxford|Boxford 260VMC]], Categories of machining are Roughing, Finishing, Slotting, Engraving, Drilling |
||
== Recommended surface speeds == |
|||
{| class="wikitable" style="margin: auto; text-align: center;" |
|||
|+Tool Speeds (m/min) |
|||
|- |
|||
! scope="col"| Material |
|||
! scope="col"| HSS |
|||
! scope="col"| Cobalt |
|||
! scope="col"| Carbide |
|||
|- |
|||
! scope="row"| Plastic |
|||
| 15 |
|||
| 15 |
|||
| Not recommended |
|||
|- |
|||
! scope="row"| Aluminium |
|||
| 100 |
|||
| 150 |
|||
| 300 |
|||
|- |
|||
! scope="row"| Brass |
|||
| 75 |
|||
| 125 |
|||
| 200 |
|||
|- |
|||
! scope="row"| Steel |
|||
| 25 |
|||
| 35 |
|||
| 65 |
|||
|- |
|||
! scope="row"| Stainless Steel |
|||
| 20 |
|||
| 25 |
|||
| 40 |
|||
|- |
|||
! scope="row"| Titanium alloys |
|||
| Not recommended |
|||
| Not recommended |
|||
| 15 |
|||
|- |
|||
! scope="row"| Tool Steels |
|||
| Not recommended |
|||
| 10 |
|||
| 30 |
|||
|} |
|||
'''NOTE : THESE ARE APPROXIMATE RECOMMENDATIONS - YOU WILL NEED TO RESEARCH ELSEWHERE AND GET EXPERIENCE IN ORDER TO PICK SPEEDS PROPERLY - IF THE TOOL MANUFACTURER'S RECOMMENDATIONS DIFFER FROM THIS TABLE, USE THE MANUFACTURER'S FIGURES INSTEAD''' |
|||
== Key == |
== Key == |
||
{| class="wikitable" |
{| class="wikitable" |
||
Line 15: | Line 62: | ||
===Roughing=== |
===Roughing=== |
||
{| class="wikitable" |
{| class="wikitable" |
||
! Tool Size |
! Tool Size || Tool Typetype !! Material !! Coating !! |
||
Surface speed |
Surface speed |
||
Line 25: | Line 72: | ||
! Comment |
! Comment |
||
|- style="background-color:#ccffcc;" |
|- style="background-color:#ccffcc;" |
||
|12mm 4-flute flat end mill || HSS || Uncoated || 100m/min || 10mm || 4mm || |
|12mm || 4-flute flat end mill || HSS || Uncoated || 100m/min || 10mm || 4mm || |
||
0.03 |
0.03 |
||
Line 31: | Line 78: | ||
||Noisy and spindle only just copes, definitely a maximum, use conventional milling only. Limited by spindle power, not tool endurance |
||Noisy and spindle only just copes, definitely a maximum, use conventional milling only. Limited by spindle power, not tool endurance |
||
|- style="background-color:#ccccff;" |
|- style="background-color:#ccccff;" |
||
|5mm 4-flute flat end mill|| HSS|| Uncoated || |
|5mm || 4-flute flat end mill|| HSS|| Uncoated || |
||
40m/min |
40m/min |
||
Line 39: | Line 86: | ||
(200mm/min) |
(200mm/min) |
||
|| Good finish, not a maximum could have done more |
|||
|- style="background-color:#ccccff;" |
|||
|3mm || 4-flute flat end mill|| HSS|| Uncoated || |
|||
28m/min |
|||
(3000rpm) |
|||
|| 1.5 mm || 1.4mm || |
|||
0.0075 |
|||
(90mm/min) |
|||
|| Good finish, not a maximum could have done more |
|| Good finish, not a maximum could have done more |
||
|- style="background-color:#ccffcc;" |
|- style="background-color:#ccffcc;" |
||
|2mm 2-flute ball nose end mill || HSS || TiAlN coated || |
|2mm || 2-flute ball nose end mill || HSS || TiAlN coated || |
||
19m/min |
19m/min |
||
Line 105: | Line 162: | ||
(120mm/min) |
(120mm/min) |
||
||Nice surface finish, might be able to go a little faster |
||Nice surface finish, might be able to go a little faster but was making noise |
||
|} |
|||
=== Engraving === |
|||
{| class="wikitable" |
|||
! Tool Size/type !! Material !! Coating !! |
|||
Surface speed |
|||
(RPM) |
|||
! DOC !! WOC !! |
|||
FTP |
|||
(feed rate) |
|||
! Comment |
|||
|- style="background-color:#ffcccc;" |
|- style="background-color:#ffcccc;" |
||
|60 degree 0.3mm tip engraver 1/8" shank || solid carbide || TiAlN coated || |
|60 degree 0.3mm tip engraver 1/8" shank || solid carbide || TiAlN coated || |
||
Line 111: | Line 181: | ||
(2500rpm) |
(2500rpm) |
||
|| N/A || 0. |
|| N/A || 0.6mm || |
||
0.02 |
0.02 |
||
(50mm/min) |
(50mm/min) |
||
||Cutter sometimes breaks, probably should try higher rpm |
||Cutter sometimes breaks, probably should try higher rpm |
||
|- style="background-color:#ccccff;" |
|||
|90 degree 0.3mm tip engraver 1/8" shank || solid carbide || TiAlN coated || |
|||
30m/min (calculated) |
|||
(3000rpm) |
|||
|| 0.25 || 0.5mm || |
|||
0.01 |
|||
(30mm/min) |
|||
||Seems to work, could maybe do deeper or faster? |
|||
|} |
|} |
||
===Slotting=== |
===Slotting=== |
||
{| class="wikitable" |
{| class="wikitable" |
||
! Tool Size |
! Tool Size || Tool type !! Material !! Coating !! |
||
Surface speed |
Surface speed |
||
Line 130: | Line 210: | ||
! Comment |
! Comment |
||
|- style="background-color:#ccffcc;" |
|- style="background-color:#ccffcc;" |
||
|4mm 4-flute flat end mill || HSS || Uncoated || |
|4mm || 4-flute flat end mill || HSS || Uncoated || |
||
31m/min |
31m/min |
||
Line 139: | Line 219: | ||
(150mm/min) |
(150mm/min) |
||
|| Using ramp profile, might be able to do more but surface finish is not good |
|| Using ramp profile, might be able to do more but surface finish is not good |
||
|- style="background-color:#ffcccc;" |
|||
|2mm || 4-flute flat end mill || HSS || Uncoated || |
|||
19m/min |
|||
(3000rpm) |
|||
|| 1.5mm || |
|||
0.01 |
|||
(120mm/min) |
|||
|| Snapped tool |
|||
|- style="background-color:#ffcccc;" |
|||
|2mm || 3-flute flat end mill || Solid carbide || Uncoated || |
|||
19m/min |
|||
(3000rpm) |
|||
|| 1.5mm || |
|||
0.015 |
|||
(90mm/min) |
|||
|| Snapped tool |
|||
|- style="background-color:#ccccff;" |
|||
| 2mm || 2-flute flat end mill || HSS || Uncoated || |
|||
19m/min |
|||
(3000rpm) |
|||
|| 1.0mm || |
|||
0.008 |
|||
(50mm/min) |
|||
|| So far so good, working up the feed rate |
|||
|- style="background-color:#ccccff;" |
|||
|3mm || 4-flute flat end mill || HSS || Uncoated || |
|||
28m/min |
|||
(3000rpm) |
|||
|| 1.5mm || |
|||
0.005 |
|||
(60mm/min) |
|||
|| FTP could be higher |
|||
|} |
|} |
||
== |
== Low-Carbon (Mild) Steel == |
||
===Roughing=== |
=== Roughing === |
||
{| class="wikitable" |
|||
! Tool Size || Tool type !! Material !! Coating !! |
|||
Surface speed |
|||
(RPM) |
|||
! DOC !! WOC !! |
|||
FTP |
|||
(feed rate) |
|||
! Comment |
|||
|- style="background-color:#ccccff;" |
|||
|4mm || 4-flute flat end mill || HSS || Uncoated || |
|||
20m/min |
|||
(1600rpm) |
|||
|| 5mm || 1.8mm || |
|||
0.02mm |
|||
(130mm/min) |
|||
|| Cut very well, probably can do more |
|||
|} |
|||
=== Drilling === |
|||
{| class="wikitable" |
|||
! Tool Size/type !! Material !! Coating !! |
|||
Surface speed |
|||
(RPM) |
|||
! |
|||
FTP |
|||
(feed rate) |
|||
! Comment |
|||
|- style="background-color:#ccccff;" |
|||
|4 mm 2-flute jobber drill|| Cobalt Steel || TiN || |
|||
20m/min |
|||
(1600rpm) |
|||
|| |
|||
0.04mm |
|||
(63mm/min) |
|||
|| Cut well, used pecking profile, probably could have done more feed |
|||
|} |
|||
== "Special" materials == |
|||
=== H-13 Tool Steel === |
|||
====Roughing==== |
|||
{| class="wikitable" |
{| class="wikitable" |
||
! Tool Size/type !! Material !! Coating !! |
! Tool Size/type !! Material !! Coating !! |
||
Line 168: | Line 335: | ||
|| Might handle more but only one test was made |
|| Might handle more but only one test was made |
||
|} |
|} |
||
===Finishing=== |
====Finishing==== |
||
{| class="wikitable" |
{| class="wikitable" |
||
! Tool Size/type !! Material !! Coating !! |
! Tool Size/type !! Material !! Coating !! |
||
Line 190: | Line 357: | ||
||Too much, breaks the tip off |
||Too much, breaks the tip off |
||
|} |
|} |
||
===Drilling=== |
====Drilling==== |
||
{| class="wikitable" |
{| class="wikitable" |
||
! Tool Size/type !! Material !! Coating !! |
! Tool Size/type !! Material !! Coating !! |
Latest revision as of 12:09, 4 April 2022
All recipes from personal experience and tested on the Boxford 260VMC, Categories of machining are Roughing, Finishing, Slotting, Engraving, Drilling
Recommended surface speeds[edit]
Material | HSS | Cobalt | Carbide |
---|---|---|---|
Plastic | 15 | 15 | Not recommended |
Aluminium | 100 | 150 | 300 |
Brass | 75 | 125 | 200 |
Steel | 25 | 35 | 65 |
Stainless Steel | 20 | 25 | 40 |
Titanium alloys | Not recommended | Not recommended | 15 |
Tool Steels | Not recommended | 10 | 30 |
NOTE : THESE ARE APPROXIMATE RECOMMENDATIONS - YOU WILL NEED TO RESEARCH ELSEWHERE AND GET EXPERIENCE IN ORDER TO PICK SPEEDS PROPERLY - IF THE TOOL MANUFACTURER'S RECOMMENDATIONS DIFFER FROM THIS TABLE, USE THE MANUFACTURER'S FIGURES INSTEAD
Key[edit]
Colour | Meaning |
---|---|
Blue | Not (proven) a maximum, could do more |
Green | A demonstrated maximum, any more will break tools |
Red | Known to be excessive, will break tools |
Aluminium[edit]
Roughing[edit]
Tool Size | Tool Typetype | Material | Coating |
Surface speed (RPM) |
DOC | WOC |
FTP (feed rate) |
Comment |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
12mm | 4-flute flat end mill | HSS | Uncoated | 100m/min | 10mm | 4mm |
0.03 (250mm/min) |
Noisy and spindle only just copes, definitely a maximum, use conventional milling only. Limited by spindle power, not tool endurance |
5mm | 4-flute flat end mill | HSS | Uncoated |
40m/min (2500rpm) |
5mm | 1.5mm |
0.02 (200mm/min) |
Good finish, not a maximum could have done more |
3mm | 4-flute flat end mill | HSS | Uncoated |
28m/min (3000rpm) |
1.5 mm | 1.4mm |
0.0075 (90mm/min) |
Good finish, not a maximum could have done more |
2mm | 2-flute ball nose end mill | HSS | TiAlN coated |
19m/min (3000rpm) |
1mm | 0.5mm |
0.02 (120mm/min) |
Works OK, 150mm/min is too much |
Brass[edit]
Roughing[edit]
Tool Size/type | Material | Coating |
Surface speed (RPM) |
DOC | WOC |
FTP (feed rate) |
Comment |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
4mm 2-flute flat end mill | HSS | Uncoated |
38m/min (3000rpm) |
1 mm | 1.8mm |
0.025 (150mm/min) |
Nice surface finish, almost certainly could do more depth |
Finishing[edit]
Tool Size/type | Material | Coating |
Surface speed (RPM) |
DOC | WOC |
FTP (feed rate) |
Comment |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1mm 3-flute flat end mill | Carbide | TiAlN coated |
9m/min (3000rpm) |
1.2 mm | 0.95mm |
0.0022 (20mm/min) |
Too much WOC, breaks cutters |
2mm 4-flute flat end mill | HSS | Uncoated |
19m/min (3000rpm) |
3 mm | 0.8mm |
0.01 (120mm/min) |
Nice surface finish, might be able to go a little faster but was making noise |
Engraving[edit]
Tool Size/type | Material | Coating |
Surface speed (RPM) |
DOC | WOC |
FTP (feed rate) |
Comment |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
60 degree 0.3mm tip engraver 1/8" shank | solid carbide | TiAlN coated |
25m/min (calculated) (2500rpm) |
N/A | 0.6mm |
0.02 (50mm/min) |
Cutter sometimes breaks, probably should try higher rpm |
90 degree 0.3mm tip engraver 1/8" shank | solid carbide | TiAlN coated |
30m/min (calculated) (3000rpm) |
0.25 | 0.5mm |
0.01 (30mm/min) |
Seems to work, could maybe do deeper or faster? |
Slotting[edit]
Tool Size | Tool type | Material | Coating |
Surface speed (RPM) |
DOC |
FTP (feed rate) |
Comment |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
4mm | 4-flute flat end mill | HSS | Uncoated |
31m/min (2500rpm) |
1mm |
0.015 (150mm/min) |
Using ramp profile, might be able to do more but surface finish is not good |
2mm | 4-flute flat end mill | HSS | Uncoated |
19m/min (3000rpm) |
1.5mm |
0.01 (120mm/min) |
Snapped tool |
2mm | 3-flute flat end mill | Solid carbide | Uncoated |
19m/min (3000rpm) |
1.5mm |
0.015 (90mm/min) |
Snapped tool |
2mm | 2-flute flat end mill | HSS | Uncoated |
19m/min (3000rpm) |
1.0mm |
0.008 (50mm/min) |
So far so good, working up the feed rate |
3mm | 4-flute flat end mill | HSS | Uncoated |
28m/min (3000rpm) |
1.5mm |
0.005 (60mm/min) |
FTP could be higher |
Low-Carbon (Mild) Steel[edit]
Roughing[edit]
Tool Size | Tool type | Material | Coating |
Surface speed (RPM) |
DOC | WOC |
FTP (feed rate) |
Comment |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
4mm | 4-flute flat end mill | HSS | Uncoated |
20m/min (1600rpm) |
5mm | 1.8mm |
0.02mm (130mm/min) |
Cut very well, probably can do more |
Drilling[edit]
Tool Size/type | Material | Coating |
Surface speed (RPM) |
FTP (feed rate) |
Comment |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
4 mm 2-flute jobber drill | Cobalt Steel | TiN |
20m/min (1600rpm) |
0.04mm (63mm/min) |
Cut well, used pecking profile, probably could have done more feed |
"Special" materials[edit]
H-13 Tool Steel[edit]
Roughing[edit]
Tool Size/type | Material | Coating |
Surface speed (RPM) |
DOC | WOC |
FTP (feed rate) |
Comment |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
6mm 4-flute flat end mill | solid carbide | TiAlN coated | 35m/min | 7mm | 0.5mm |
0.04mm |
Width is at maximum, depth might be deeper |
1mm 3-flute flat end mill | Solid Carbide | TiAlN coated |
9.4m/min (3000rpm) |
0.5mm | 0.5mm |
0.0022mm (20mm/min) |
Might handle more but only one test was made |
Finishing[edit]
Tool Size/type | Material | Coating |
Surface speed (RPM) |
DOC | WOC |
FTP (feed rate) |
Comment |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
20 degree 0.3mm tip engraver 1/8" shank | solid carbide | TiAlN coated |
30m/min (calculated) (3000rpm) |
0.5 mm | 0.15mm |
0.0026 (8mm/min) |
Too much, breaks the tip off |
Drilling[edit]
Tool Size/type | Material | Coating |
Surface speed (RPM) |
FTP (feed rate) |
Comment |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
6mm 2-flute jobber drill | HSS | TiN |
14m/min (730rpm) |
0.02mm (15mm/min) |
Was in danger of stalling spindle, definitely the maximum size that can be drilled in this material |